#IRS - Rely on Our Guidance at Your Peril

In a truly Alice in Wonderland moment, the Unites States #TaxCourt issued an order in which the Court says that #IRS guidance "is not binding precedent and that taxpayers rely on same at their own peril." What?

Okay, maybe the #TaxCourt meant that you can't rely on something a clerk tells you on the phone or at your local #IRS office. Maybe the #IRS representative was not authorized to issue the guidance, or perhaps they misconstrued the #TaxCode - you might understand how that could happen. 

Not the case. The #TaxCourt Order in  Bobrow, Docket No. 7022-11, dated ironically enough April 15, 2014, warns taxpayers that they can't rely on #IRS guidance.

Looking deeper into the case, the advice was actually contained in an IRS publication, Number 590 to be precise. The #TaxCourt stated that reliance on Publication 590 "would not have served as substantial authority for the position taken on their tax returns."

The American College of Tax Counsel filed an Amicus brief in support of the taxpayer's motion for reconsideration. The ACTC argued that the #IRS' position could undermine public confidence in the tax system. How can you penalize a taxpayer for reliance on published IRS guidelines?

The taxpayer made an argument that reasonable people could agree on - I'll pay the additional tax due, but don't charge me a penalty. The taxpayer's position was in accord with the published #IRS guidelines, so sounds good on all sides. The lesson is that reasonable arguments don't win in #TaxCort or with the #IRS - its form over substance. 

 “But I don't want to go among mad people," Alice remarked.
"Oh, you can't help that," said the Cat: "we're all mad here. I'm mad. You're mad."
"How do you know I'm mad?" said Alice.
"You must be," said the Cat, "or you wouldn't have come here.” 
― Lewis Carroll, Alice in Wonderland


#Austin-Tax-Help #SATaxHelp
 










Popular posts from this blog

5 Types of IRS Offers You Need to Know About

Image
  If you're struggling with IRS debt, it can feel overwhelming and stressful. However, there are options available to help you resolve your tax debt and move forward with your financial future. One of these options is an IRS offer, which comes in five different types. Learn more about these offers and how they can help you get back on track.   Offer in Compromise. An Offer in Compromise (OIC) is one of the most well-known types of IRS offers. It allows taxpayers to settle their tax debt for less than the full amount owed. To qualify for an OIC, taxpayers must demonstrate that they are unable to pay their full tax debt, either through a lump sum payment or through a payment plan. The IRS will consider factors such as income, expenses, and asset equity when evaluating an OIC. It's important to note that not all taxpayers will qualify for an OIC, and it should only be pursued after consulting with a tax professional.   Installment Agreement. An Installment Agreement is
Read more

Unlocking the Secrets of an Offer in Compromise: A Comprehensive Guide - Chapter 4

  Chapter 4 – Filing Details/Payment Terms/Important Consequences IRS FORM 656 – OFFER IN COMPROMISE Use IRS form 656, Offer in Compromise to submit your offer. You can access the form via this link .   Be sure to read the accompanying booklet. Note that there are different forms of Form 433, Collection Information Statement, that are a part of the submission process. Form 433-A is for use by Wage Earners and Self-Employed Individuals. Form 433-B is used by Businesses. Also note that there is a specific form, 656-L, for use if you are claiming doubt as to liability. The IRS site also has a pre-qualifier tool. But don’t get too upset if it reports that you are not eligible. The tool does not take into account any special circumstances or other issues that may be relevant to your situation. Please refer back to this section of my Blog for a more detailed discussion of this issue.   Who Can File An Offer? An Offer in Compromise (OIC) can be filed by any individual or busines
Read more

Unlocking the Secrets of an Offer in Compromise: A Comprehensive Guide Chapter 3 - How Much Do I Offer?

  Calculating the Amount of your Offer in Compromise – What is Your Reasonable Collection Potential (RCP)? Drum roll please! This is what you’ve been searching for – how much do I offer? How little can I get away with? Why not low ball them?   Here are the two most important concepts to understand before you start your OIC.   Key Point 1 - You’re not buying a car or a house. The Settlement Agent does not work on commission. They don’t have to settle and the decision to settle rests entirely with the Settlement Officer. Any offer or counter-offer you make has to be backed up by the numbers.   Key Point 2 – Determine your Reasonable Collection Potential before making an offer. Reasonable Collection Potential (RCP) is a key factor considered by the IRS when evaluating an Offer in Compromise (OIC). RCP refers to the amount of money the IRS believes it can collect from a taxpayer based on their assets, income, and future earning potential.   The IRS will consider a taxpaye
Read more